Here I have channelised all the inputs and incorporated customer feedbacks which needs to worked upon to improve the product.
Lets start to first Listing the Ideal customer profiles for AdaniOne transport services which is trains and buses.
The two ICPs listed are the ideal profile of the customers who are the target audience and are highly intended people to uses these services basis their routine and necessities.
Approach
Thinking of the person for whom this product will have perfect market fit. They are majorly belonging to tier 2, 3 cities and have now migrated to tier 1 cities in order to have better jobs and lifestyles.
These people prefer convenience and easy to understand ux ui and have high frequency of train bookings.
While the other person is still routed to the origin but often travels to meet their relatives, they are not the regular user of the app but have hight intent of being loyal customer considering the pricing structure and competitiveness.
β
Ideal Customer profile | ICP 1 | ICP 2 |
ICP Name | Tarun | Alisha |
Age | 25-40 years | 20-30 years |
Travel Goals | Get access to wide variety of travel options at best prices | Maximise travel within given budget |
Income Levels | 20k- 60k per month | 5k-15k per month |
Gender | Male | Female |
Location | Tier 1,2,3 cities in India like Delhi, Kanpur, Etawa, Lucknow, Amritsar | Tier 3,4 cities in India like Vijaywada, Bihar, Jhansi, Mauranipur |
Companies | Own business, pvt jobs, government jobs, prep for govt. services | Housewife, interns, travelling for job, early jobers |
Marital Status | Both married and unmarried | Both married and unmarried |
How do they spend their weekdays | 1. Working 2. Socialising with friends | 1. At college/work 2. Going out with friends/ colleagues 3. Household chores |
How do they spend their weekends | 1. Spend time with family at home 2. Watching Tv/OTT 3. Calling friends home for party | 1. Hanging out with friends/chilling 2. At home watching OTT/social media 3. Shopping with friends |
Apps they spends most of their time on | 1. Instagram, YT, 2. Messaging apps- whatsapp | 1. Social Media- IG, YT 2. Messaging/dating apps- Tinder, whatsapp 3. OTT apps |
What do they spend most on | Petrol, Rent, savings | Shopping, Grocery, Household expenses |
Frequency of feature usage | Open the app- once every 3 days Wishlist- once a week Add to cart/buy- once a month | Open the app- once a week Wishlist- once a fortnight Add to cart/buy- once in 2 months |
Willingness to pay | High value seeking cohort. They would be ready to pay for the convenience and service if they like would book again | Moderate Value seeking cohort because of limited budget. They would be searching extensively for options from both offline and online and then finally buy whichever is a better fit and lower price |
Problem Statement | Too many apps in the ecosystem would trust the direct app but one loyal then sticks to the platform also create WOM | Always seeking better price |
How technically sophisticated are they?
| Moderate | Low |
What role do they play in decision making process
| High | Low |
What technologies are they using?
| Laptop, mobile, smartwatch, tablet | Mobile |
Are they more driven by a desire to be innovative, or reduce risk
| Ready to explore with the created noise in market | Ready to explore only after checking the offers and pricing |
Time Vs features | Time is important | Features is important |
β
Looking at the demographics and the kind of traffic we are receiving on the platform ; it is observed that maximum bookings are being done by male user that female. It seems that the male person is booking services from their account.
There are more male travellers than female travellers hence it is an opportunity to grab the female driven booking by proving more security features or communication which targets the female audience and encourage the travel.
The maximum booking is of AC services than the non-Ac ones , around 72% of bookings comprises of AC bookings and only 28% is the non-AC bookings blended for both Trains and buses.
β
β
β
On further deduction and analysis the traffic bases on city wise bookings, here is the pie chart for the same. It is seen that 8.1% bookings are done for bengaluru route followed by Ahmedabad and Delhi.
Maximum searches have been contributed by Maharatra state followed by Uttar Pradesh, Here is the detailed searches data in descending order :
β
Region | Overall Bus Search |
Maharashtra | 714 |
Uttar Pradesh | 548 |
Delhi | 390 |
Gujarat | 357 |
Karnataka | 352 |
Rajasthan | 298 |
Madhya Pradesh | 272 |
Tamil Nadu | 250 |
Telangana | 245 |
West Bengal | 191 |
Haryana | 106 |
Punjab | 87 |
Andhra Pradesh | 68 |
Kerala | 64 |
Odisha | 63 |
Bihar | 60 |
Chandigarh | 31 |
Himachal Pradesh | 22 |
Uttarakhand | 20 |
Assam | 17 |
Jammu and Kashmir | 13 |
Chhattisgarh | 9 |
Jharkhand | 9 |
(not set) | 7 |
Mizoram | 6 |
Dubai | 4 |
England | 2 |
Florida | 2 |
Goa | 2 |
Nagaland | 2 |
Tripura | 2 |
Andaman and Nicobar Islands | 1 |
Eastern Province | 1 |
Federal Territory of Kuala Lumpur | 1 |
Illinois | 1 |
Manipur | 1 |
Massachusetts | 1 |
Meghalaya | 1 |
Ontario | 1 |
Samara Oblast | 1 |
Texas | 1 |
Functional (primary) : Providing integrated service for all travel needs
Social (secondary) : Self booking app ecosystem, no thirds party support required
Financial (brand) : To generate growth by maximising the traffic and user onboarding
β
Case Category | Case Sub Category | Total Count | %Age |
Buses |
| 51 | |
Operator / Bus Issue | 20 | 39% | |
Bus Delayed | 9 | 18% | |
Quick resolution | 8 | 16% | |
Great app experience | 8 | 16% | |
Contact Details of operator/Driver | 4 | 8% | |
Boarding Location | 2 | 4% | |
Train Related |
| 220 | |
Cancelled PNR refund | 67 | 30% | |
Refund not received | 59 | 27% | |
Booking status | 58 | 26% | |
Train status /Info | 12 | 5% | |
Booking query | 6 | 3% | |
Refund Breakup | 4 | 2% | |
Others | 14 | 6% | |
Grand Total |
| 271 |
|
β
Google Slide Link:
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1NA6P6NNRIrv-4CQwJ-TXP3iifrDxe-qlgdfSrYdUKHM/edit?usp=sharing
D1 : the focus is on the first-time user experience (FTUE)
For tracking the first time user experience we first called up our this week first 10 users and took their honest feedback
Questions covered -
Questions | Customer 1 | Customer 2 | Customer 3 | Customer 4 | Customer 5 | Customer 6 | Customer 7 | Customer 8 | Customer 9 | Customer 10 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Any issues with the app download | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
Did you face any issues with the signup | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
Look and feel of the app was good? | Yes | Yes | No, find redbus better | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Were they able to identify various services of AdaniOne | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Train / bus booking ecosystem was easy to understand | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Was customer able to make seemless booking | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Issues logging in to IRCTC account | yes some lag | No | No | No | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | No |
Any issues on the payment flow or page | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
Overall Rating | 5/5 | 4/5 | 3/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 |
β
D7 : Users who have progressed further into the core
For Trains - Monthly 62% of the people are actually converting their searches to landing to the "Select Seat" page
β
Below is the date to back uo the analysis
β
β
For Bus - Monthly 44% of the people are actually converting their searches to landing to the "Select Seat" page
Below is the date to back up the analysis
β
β
β
D30 retentions : Users may have reached end page and may become bored or dissatisfied. This is when adanione needs to examine the deeper aspects of the customer retention.
As maximum drop has been detected in the last step and people are actually ending or dropping out of the app.
Recommendation to start showing some sort of offer or gratify this customer as their are high chances that user has found better prices else where.
Secondly the we have detected the payment failure rate to another cause of the drop, hence need to improve the success rate of the payments or just reflect upi as the payment method as it contributes more than 75% of the success transactions.
For Trains daily active users are 5059 and monthly active 216165 users
For Buses daily active users are 1978 and monthly active 48622 users
β
Engagement Rate : 78.22%
β
Bus Pages | Users |
Home Page | 3560 |
Listing Page | 2052 |
Review | 736 |
Payment Page | 325 |
Hypothesis 1 : Time taken to create an event
β
For testing this hypothesis, I recorded the journey from opening app till booking calculating the overall time taken to search and book.
Test Condition 1 : When user knows exactly which train / bus it want to book
In this situation the average train booking time was 1 minute and for bus it took 40seconds .
The payment page took another 20 seconds in both the journey with UPI/secured card as payment method.
Test Condition 2 : When user wanted to test and explore pricing and offers available on the platform
Here the it me aprox 2min in trains to fully explore the functionality checking all cancellation policies offers till booking.
β
Hypothesis 2 : % users who made the reservation
More folks are completing their bus bookings (10.97%) than train bookings (7.36%). I'm wondering if that's because of differences in ticket prices, seat availability, or just personal travel style.
Hypothesis 3 : Highest drop step in onboarding
We're losing a lot of potential passengers after they search for their ride, especially on the bus side. It seems like something right after that search step isn't clicking with them
As overall bus searched in a month is 2379 vs completed bookings in only 261
Where as for trains overall searched in a month is 2527 vs completed bookings is only 186 .
Hypothesis 4 : Reserved vs actual attendees
Method : For both the businesses we checked the number of people who have made the payment successfully vs who have completed the journey
Train : 267 people made the payments, out of them only 186 passengers have actually availed the services contributing to 69% drop
Bus : 233 people made the payments, out of them only 181 passengers have actually availed the services contributing to 77% converted
TRAINS & BUSES β
We use various acquiring sources all of them listed as below :
Β· Direct
Β· Paid Search (cpc) β cost per click
Β· Cross network
Β· Organic Search
Β· Affiliates
Β· Paid social
Β· Referral
Β· Push notifications on phone
Β· SMS
Β· Email
Β· Banner displays
Β· Paid video
In a month
Train month searches = 2527
Users who have selected order completed their searches = 1064
β
Search to book conversion - 7.36%
β
Session | Channel |
Direct,(none),23418 | |
Paid | Search,cpc,14096 |
Cross-network,cpc,7810 | |
Unassigned,(not | set),7497 |
Organic | Search,organic,1719 |
Affiliates,affiliate,537 | |
Paid | Social,cpc,400 |
Referral,referral,375 | |
Mobile | Push, Notifications,whatsapp_push,94 |
SMS,sms,77 | |
Unassigned,(none),52 | |
Email,email,31 | |
Mobile | Notifications,banner_push,30 |
Display,banner,26 | |
Display,cpc,26 | |
Unassigned,chatbot,23 | |
Organic | Social,social,21 |
Unassigned,affiliate_171_,18 | |
Paid | Other,cpc,15 |
Organic | Search,referral,13 |
Organic | Social,referral,13 |
Unassigned,digitalpromotion,13 | |
Organic | Social,skyscanner,11 |
Display,display,6 | |
Organic | Social,google_flight,5 |
Paid | Video,cpc,4 |
Organic | Social,push,3 |
Organic | Search,search,2 |
Organic | Social,sms,2 |
Organic | Social,whatsapp_push,1 |
β
β
β
β
Top 5 best product reviews on app store >>
β
β
β
β
The user onboaring and teardown will help building the product and strong positioning in the market.
The customer feedbacks are most critical part hence needs to be worked upon and problems related to user experience should be solve in immediate priority.
Also since the drop from search to booking is higher hence its recommended to focus more on the marketing channels and communications as currently the app is low with the market discovery.
Overall product experience is so far good but constant improvement is necessary here.
β
Brand focused courses
Great brands aren't built on clicks. They're built on trust. Craft narratives that resonate, campaigns that stand out, and brands that last.
All courses
Master every lever of growth β from acquisition to retention, data to events. Pick a course, go deep, and apply it to your business right away.
Explore foundations by GrowthX
Built by Leaders From Amazon, CRED, Zepto, Hindustan Unilever, Flipkart, paytm & more
Crack a new job or a promotion with the Career Centre
Designed for mid-senior & leadership roles across growth, product, marketing, strategy & business
Learning Resources
Browse 500+ case studies, articles & resources the learning resources that you won't find on the internet.
Patienceβyouβre about to be impressed.